Mitch Marner's Contract Talks Stir the Pot in Toronto

As whispers surrounding his upcoming contract negotiations gain momentum, the figures being floated are bound to stir unease among the Leafs' faithful.

Traditionally, the NHL market adjusts dynamically as each superstar queues up for their turn at unrestricted free agency. It was not long ago that Nathan MacKinnon held the title of the highest-paid player, a crown swiftly taken by Auston Matthews after signing his new deal. Many speculated that Leon Draisaitl would follow, yet current murmurs suggest Marner's representation is aiming significantly higher.

While it's prudent to approach these figures with skepticism, insider sources hint at Marner's camp initiating talks in the lofty range of $13M to $14M AAV (average annual value). Though initial negotiation phases typically see such high numbers, realistic expectations might place the final figure between $12.7M and $12.9M per season, according to a recent rumour from

Such a contract would not only eclipse William Nylander's by approximately $1.2 million annually but would also position Marner as the NHL's second-highest-paid player, trailing only his teammate Matthews. The comparison doesn't end there; Marner's team is reportedly using Artemi Panarin's contract as a benchmark, which, adjusted for today's salary cap, equates to about $13.2 million, detailed further in a follow-up post

This potential outcome could place Toronto in a precarious position financially. If Marner's salary lands around $12.7 million, he, Matthews, and Nylander would collectively command $37.45 million of the projected $92 million cap for the 2025-26 season, a significant chunk that could limit the Leafs' flexibility.

The 2024-25 season looms large for Marner, arguably his most crucial yet. In a contract year, the spotlight intensifies, and with high expectations comes the pressure to deliver a performance justifying such a steep price tag. A standout season from Marner would not only bolster his case for a lucrative deal but could also propel the Maple Leafs deep into the playoffs, aligning individual success with team achievements.

However, the road ahead is fraught with challenges. As the clock ticks down, the pressure mounts�not just on Marner, but on the entire organization to navigate these complex financial waters without capsizing their competitive aspirations.

Source for cap info: PuckPedia
Maple Leafs salary information